Economics in 30 Minutes, Part 1: Scarcity, Choices, and Models Transcript of the narration (times approximate) The Next Best Economist · © 2026 Vincent Maistre · CC BY 4.0 · thenextbesteconomist.com Introduction (0:00) This is an overview of introductory economics, and mostly of microeconomics, the part about people, firms and prices. A real course takes fifteen weeks and a fair amount of math. This is a short introduction in four parts, and it leaves most of the math out on purpose. What you'll get instead is the way economists think, which is a habit of asking certain questions more than it is a set of facts. So I'm going to ask you some. Twice in this part I'll ask you to pause the video and actually do something. You'll get more out of it that way. What economics is (0:38) Here's the definition I'll be using, and it's on the screen so I won't read it to you. The first half of it is about you: what you choose when you can't have it all. The second half is about what happens when a few hundred million people make those choices at the same time, and the choices start to collide. The reason you can't have everything is scarcity, and scarcity is easy to misunderstand, so let me be careful about it. Your day has twenty-four hours in it and there is no way to get a twenty-fifth. The beach has a certain number of houses on it. The front row has a certain number of seats. Even billionaires can't buy back yesterday afternoon. People hear scarcity and think poverty. That's the misunderstanding. A thing is scarce when there isn't enough of it for everyone to have all they'd like at a price of zero, and by that test almost everything is scarce, in rich countries and poor ones alike. What differs between them is which things are scarce, and for whom. Because things are scarce, every choice has a cost, and I don't mean the price on the tag. When you take one thing, you give up the chance at another. Economists have a name for the value of the best alternative you passed over: the opportunity cost. Only the best alternative counts, because you could only have done one of them anyway. We'll spend real time on this in Part 4; it's the most useful idea in the subject. Keep a question in the back of your mind as we go. What is scarce for you this week? Pick something that isn't money. And what's the best alternative you're giving up right now, by watching this instead? The end of scarcity? (2:26) Every so often somebody announces that scarcity is about to end. In 1930, John Maynard Keynes wrote an essay called "Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren," and in it he guessed that within about a hundred years the economic problem might be solved, or close to it. A hundred years from 1930 is about 2030, which is roughly now. We're the grandchildren. Elon Musk goes further than Keynes did. Speaking to a conference in Paris in May of 2024, he said that with AI and robots probably none of us will have a job, that there will be a universal high income, and that there will be no shortage of goods or services. In December 2025 he put it even more simply: there will be no poverty in the future, so there's no need to save money. Let me give that forecast its best case, because it has one. AI can already make tutoring, translation, routine writing and a lot of software very cheap. Robots can cut the labor that goes into making things. Put cheap energy together with automation and we could produce far more than we do now. Some things that are scarce today may become nearly free, and that wouldn't be new. Artificial light used to be expensive. So did a phone call across the country. A map of the whole world used to be something you kept in a glove box, and now it's in your pocket. Now the question an economist would ask. No poverty is not the same as no scarcity. If you make everything cheap, you don't get rid of scarcity. You move it. Something else becomes the scarce thing. Here's a restaurant where the robots make dinner for free. Seconds are free, dessert is free, and nobody has to tip. And everyone who walks in points at the same table, the one by the window. The robots can make another dinner any time. What they can't do is give everyone that same table, with that view, at seven-thirty on a Saturday. So what stays scarce when production is nearly free? Land in a particular place, because they aren't making more of it where you want to live. A time slot, because seven-thirty on Saturday only happens once a week. Your attention, because there are only so many hours you can give to anything. One specific painting, because a copy isn't the thing. And the energy, the minerals and the chips that the robots themselves run on. When the money price of something falls to zero, the question of who gets it doesn't go away. Something else has to answer it. Maybe a line, maybe a lottery, maybe a reservation list, or a membership, or who you know, or a political decision. Hold on to that restaurant. We'll come back to it at the end of this part, and again at the end of the series. Micro, macro, and what a model is (5:36) Two quick words before we start, because you'll hear them constantly. Microeconomics is about the choices people and firms make, and how the markets they make them in interact with each other: beer, apartments, the market for nurses, and the way a change in one of those reaches the others. Macroeconomics is about the whole economy at once: inflation, unemployment, growth. This series is mostly micro. And one more word, which needs a drawing. Model. What is this? A happy face. Thank you. Does it look like anyone you know? No. But you knew what it was. Suppose I took twenty minutes and drew a realistic one, with shading and eyelashes and the works. Would that help? It wouldn't. It would still be a face with a smile, and you'd get the same information twenty minutes later. That's the first thing to know about a model: it doesn't have to look like the real thing to be useful. Now look at what I left out. There are no ears, no hair, no nose. People have those. I left them out because they don't matter for the question I was asking, which was, what is this person feeling? A model keeps what matters for the question and drops the rest, or sets it aside to deal with separately. Most of economics is deciding what not to draw. Now I'll erase the mouth and draw a frown. What changed, and what does it mean? One line changed, and the meaning changed with it. Everything else is exactly where it was, so you know what did it. The mouth did. Economists have a Latin phrase for this, ceteris paribus, which means other things equal. Change one thing, hold everything else still, and you can see what that one thing does. You'll hear the English version, all else equal, all through Parts 2 and 3, and this is what it means. Your turn with the chalk. Pause the video and draw three more faces, as simple as mine: surprise, anger, and a wink. Change one feature at a time, and notice which feature is doing the work. Then two harder questions. Would everyone read your faces the way you meant them? And could my smile mean something other than happy? It could be sincere, or polite, or sarcastic, and the drawing can't tell you which. Every model has that limit. It carries the information it was built to carry, for the question it was built to answer. Change the question, and something you left out can suddenly matter. Try putting glasses on this face and see how far you get without a nose. One honest caution before we go on. On a chalkboard I can hold everything else still, because I'm holding the chalk. In real data, several things change at the same time, and holding the rest fixed is much harder. That's why it's so hard to tell what caused what, and Part 4 is largely about that problem. Your turn (8:55) Before Part 2, one exercise. Take it seriously, because we'll come back to your answers at the end of the series. Suppose a new technology makes housing, food and ordinary goods cost ninety percent less than they do now. The same apartment, the same groceries, the same things in the same stores, at a tenth of the price. For now, assume your income stays exactly what it is. First, how would your own life change? What would you buy more of? And here's the part to think about: would you spend more dollars on it, or fewer? Buying more of something can mean spending less on it, when the price has fallen that far. Second, what happens to the money you're no longer spending? You could buy something else with it, save it, pay down a debt, or decide to work fewer hours. There's no right answer; the point is to notice you have the choice. Third, let everyone else make the same kind of adjustment, including changes in how much they work and what they earn. What happens to the things people now want more of? Which businesses grow, and whose job changes? And the question this whole part has been building toward. What is still scarce? Name something specific. How do you think it would be allocated, who would get it and who wouldn't? And how should it be allocated? Those are two different questions, and the second one needs you to say what you mean by should. Next (10:36) Part 2 asks a question that sounds stupid. Why does anything cost what it costs?