Transcript
Economics in 30 Minutes, Part 3: How Markets Change
The narration, word for word, as heard in the video. Times are approximate. Plain-text version for pasting into an AI tutor · Back to the companion page
Introduction (0:00)
Part 2 ended with a graph: demand sloping down, supply sloping up, a price where they cross. This part moves the lines. By the end you'll be able to take almost any price story you hear and say which line moved, which way, and what that does to the price. Two pauses again, one in the middle and one at the end.
Movement along the line, and the line moving (0:24)
Here's where we left off. Beer, price up the side, quantity along the bottom, and the crossing point, with everything else in the world held still. The whole of this part is about what happens when something in the world refuses to hold still.
First, the thing most people get wrong, so we'll get it right now. Suppose beer gets cheaper. People buy more beer. On the graph, that's a slide along the demand line, from a high point to a lower one. The line itself hasn't gone anywhere. The price of beer is already on the graph, up the side, so a change in beer's own price can only move you along the line you already drew.
Now suppose something else changes. Not the price of beer; something off the page. At every price, people now want more beer than they did before. That isn't a slide along the line; that's the whole line moving, to the right. So here's the rule for everything that follows. Beer's own price moves you along the demand line. Anything else that matters moves the line.
PPPINTE (1:35)
Here's the list we're going to build. Beer's own price goes in a box at the top, because it's the one that moves you along the line and it keeps trying to sneak onto the list of things that move the line. Everything below it moves the line. Six of them. We'll do three slowly and three fast.
Start with substitutes, things people buy instead of beer. Wine, mostly. Suppose a bad harvest pushes wine to eighteen dollars a bottle. Some wine drinkers decide beer will do. At every beer price, more beer is wanted than before, so the demand line moves right. Where it crosses supply, both the price and the quantity of beer are higher than they were. Notice the order: wine's price changed first, then beer's demand moved, then beer's price followed.
Second, income. When people have more money, they buy more of most things, ordinary beer included, so demand shifts right and the price and quantity rise. A cheap beer can go the other way: as people earn more, they may buy less of it and trade up. Economists call that an inferior good. Inferior here describes how demand responds to income, not the quality of the beer. The supplement has more on normal and inferior goods. Put the line back where it was before the next one.
Third, tastes. Craft beer becomes fashionable and demand moves right. A few years later everyone decides they drink hard seltzer now, and demand moves left; lower price, lower quantity, and the breweries didn't do anything wrong. Tastes are the shifter with no price attached. Nothing about any price changed first; people simply wanted something different.
Three more, fast, each one an arrow on the same graph. Complements are things you buy with beer, like wings or pizza; make them cheaper and beer demand moves right. The number of buyers: a college opens down the road, and demand moves right. And expectations.
If people expect the price to go up on Monday, they buy on Saturday. Today's demand moves right, because of a price that hasn't happened yet. Beer keeps, so people can stock up before Monday.
Here's the whole list. Beer's own price in the box, and then the six shifters: the price of substitutes, the price of complements, income, the number of buyers, tastes, expectations. Read the first letters and you get a word that is almost a word. PPPINTE. It's ugly, and students remember it, which is the only test a mnemonic has to pass. Everything on the list except the beer's own price moves the line.
Supply moves too (4:37)
Now the other line. Supply moves when something changes for the breweries. Take hops, which every beer needs. If hops get expensive, then at every beer price the breweries want to brew less than before, so the supply line moves left. The crossing moves up and to the left: a higher price, and less beer sold. Same kind of move as demand, on the other blade.
This happened. On the second of October 2006, a hop warehouse in Yakima, Washington burned, and with it about two million pounds of hops, around four percent of the American crop. On its own that might have been a blip, but it landed after years of shrinking hop acreage and just before two poor harvests. Brewers paid more for hops, some couldn't get them at all, and beer prices rose in 2007 and 2008. The fire tightened a supply that was already strained, and that's why a four percent loss hurt as much as it did.
The mix-ups (5:46)
Now the mix-ups, because knowing the tool means knowing how people misuse it. Here's a bakery at closing time with bread left on the shelves. The baker says nobody wants bread anymore. Is that right? In the first case the price went from three dollars to nine, and the customer walked. That's a slide along the demand line. Nothing about demand changed; the quantity people buy at nine dollars is lower than at three. In the second case the price is still three and the customer has gone keto. That is the demand line moving. Same bread left on the shelves, two different stories, and only the second one is a change in demand.
Which brings us to a sentence that has ended a lot of exam careers. Demand went up, so the price went up, so demand went down. The first two parts are fine: demand shifted right, and the price rose. The third part is the error. The higher price moves buyers along the new demand line. It doesn't shift the line back. Demand is the whole line. Quantity demanded is where you are on it. Keep those two apart and most of this subject gets easier.
The other common mix-up is blaming the wrong line. A refinery goes down and gas jumps forty cents overnight, and someone will explain it as people suddenly wanting more gas. Nobody wanted more gas. Supply fell. The habit to build is to ask, before anything else, whether the thing that changed happened to the buyers or to the sellers. That one question sorts most stories.
What the graph can and can't tell you (7:33)
A word about what this tool can and can't do. It tells you direction. Hop fire, price up, quantity down. It does not tell you how much, because the lines I drew are sketches. Real demand and supply curves take data, much of it private, and a lot of tedious work to estimate. The arrows are honest. The lengths are guesses.
And it gets harder when two things move at once, which in the real world they usually do. Suppose incomes rise and the hops burn in the same month. Beer is a normal good, so demand goes right; supply goes left. Both of those push the price up, so the price rises for certain. But one of them raises quantity and the other lowers it, so which way quantity goes depends on which shift is bigger, and the graph alone can't say. That's not a failure of the tool. That's the tool telling you exactly what you'd need to find out.
One last sorting rule, the one from the 1900 stories. A century ago the economist Irving Fisher complained that people blamed rising prices on profiteers, speculators, middlemen and trusts. His point was that any of those can raise one price. Mine is narrower: explaining one price doesn't explain a rise in all of them. For that you have to look at spending and production across the whole economy, and that's macroeconomics, for another video.
Your turn (9:09)
Your turn. Three questions, all on the beer graph. Assume ordinary beer, so more income means more beer; assume wine and beer are substitutes; and leave beer supply where it is. Draw each change from the original graph, and keep track of which market you're drawing.
One. Everyone in the beer market gets more income. Which line moves, which way, and what happens to the price and the quantity of beer?
Two. Bad weather destroys a big European wine-grape harvest. Start in the wine market and work out what happens there. Then cross over to the beer market and trace it through.
Three. Now both happen in the same season. Do the two effects on beer reinforce each other or fight each other? What can you say for certain, and what would you need to know to say how big the change is?
Next (10:10)
Part 4 is the toolbox: opportunity cost, comparative advantage, sunk cost, and the hardest one, how you tell what caused what.